Ideas from Darren

Why Making Mistakes Is Essential for Learning: What Neuroscience Teaches Us About the Brain

Progress Over Perfection Learning Through Mistakes

What if the mistakes you’ve spent your life trying to avoid are actually some of your greatest opportunities to learn?

From an early age, many of us are taught to associate mistakes with failure.

At school, incorrect answers are marked with red crosses. In the workplace, errors can lead to criticism. And in everyday life, we sometimes feel embarrassed when we get something wrong.

Gradually, we may begin to believe that making mistakes is something we should avoid at all costs.

But neuroscience tells us something fascinating.

Our brains are constantly learning from experience, and mistakes can provide valuable information that helps us adjust our behaviour, improve our skills and develop new understanding.

In fact, learning from mistakes is one of the ways our brains adapt to the world around us.

This is closely connected to neuroplasticity, the brain’s remarkable ability to change in response to experience and learning.

Whether you’re learning to play a musical instrument, developing a new professional skill, recovering from a life-changing experience or simply trying something unfamiliar, mistakes can play an important role in your progress.

The question is not whether you will make mistakes.

It’s what you choose to learn from them.

1. Why Does the Brain Learn From Mistakes?

The human brain is constantly making predictions.

When we perform an action, our brain uses previous experiences and available information to anticipate what might happen next.

Sometimes those predictions are correct.

Sometimes they are not.

When the outcome differs from what we expected, the brain can use that difference as information.

Scientists often describe this as a prediction error.

Prediction errors are involved in several forms of learning, including reinforcement learning, where outcomes help influence future decisions and behaviours.

Imagine trying to throw a ball into a basket.

On your first attempt, the ball falls short.

Your brain receives information about the movement and the result.

On your next attempt, you adjust the amount of force.

Perhaps the ball travels too far.

You adjust again.

Over repeated attempts, you may become more accurate.

The mistakes provide feedback that can help you refine your movements.

A similar process can occur when learning an instrument, practising a language or developing a new skill.

However, mistakes do not automatically produce learning. We also need useful feedback, opportunities to practise and an understanding of what to change.

The mistake provides information. Learning happens when we use that information constructively.

2. The Connection Between Mistakes and Neuroplasticity

Neuroplasticity refers to the brain’s ability to modify its structure, connections and functions in response to experience, learning and other influences.

It is one of the foundations of lifelong learning.

When we practise a new skill, networks of neurons are involved in processing information and coordinating our responses.

With experience and repetition, connections within these networks can change.

This can contribute to improvements in performance.

Mistakes can become part of that learning process because they highlight differences between what we intended to achieve and what actually happened.

For example, imagine learning a new word in a foreign language.

You pronounce it incorrectly.

Someone helps you understand the correct pronunciation.

You listen carefully and try again.

Over time, with practice and feedback, your pronunciation may improve.

This involves learning-related changes in the brain.

But it is important to understand that neuroplasticity is not simply about making mistakes.

It is influenced by practice, attention, feedback, motivation, sleep and many other factors.

Repeatedly making the same mistake without understanding why may reinforce an ineffective habit rather than improve performance.

That is why reflection and constructive feedback matter.

3. What Happens in the Brain When We Make an Error?

Researchers have identified brain processes involved in detecting and responding to mistakes.

One area associated with performance monitoring is the anterior cingulate cortex, which forms part of a wider network involved in detecting conflict, monitoring outcomes and adjusting behaviour.

Scientists studying electrical activity in the brain have also identified a response known as error-related negativity, or ERN.

This electrical signal can occur shortly after someone makes certain types of errors.

It provides researchers with a way to study how the brain monitors performance.

However, detecting an error is not the same as successfully learning from it.

The brain may recognise that something went wrong without immediately knowing how to correct it.

Effective learning often requires additional information.

This might come from a teacher, a colleague, a coach or the results of another attempt.

The important point is that mistakes are not simply interruptions to learning.

They can be an important source of information within the learning process.

4. Why Fear of Failure Can Prevent Us From Learning

One of the greatest barriers to learning is not necessarily a lack of ability.

Sometimes, it is the fear of getting something wrong.

Think about how many people avoid learning a new language because they worry about mispronouncing words.

Or how many adults hesitate to learn an instrument because they believe they will sound terrible.

Some people avoid public speaking because they fear forgetting their words.

Others refuse to attempt unfamiliar technology because they don’t want to appear inexperienced.

The problem is that avoiding mistakes can also mean avoiding opportunities to learn.

When we only participate in activities we already know how to do, we may have fewer opportunities to develop unfamiliar skills.

This does not mean we should deliberately make mistakes or ignore situations where errors could cause harm.

In healthcare, engineering, driving and many other activities, preventing mistakes is critically important.

But in safe learning environments, being willing to attempt something difficult can be valuable.

You cannot become experienced at something without first accepting that you may be inexperienced.

And inexperience often involves mistakes.

5. What Learning Piano at 54 Taught Me About Mistakes

I started learning to play the piano at 54.

One of the things I quickly appreciated was that learning a musical instrument requires patience.

You may know which notes you want to play, but your fingers do not always cooperate.

You might play the wrong key.

You may struggle to coordinate both hands.

Or perhaps you play a familiar passage correctly several times before suddenly making a mistake.

It can be frustrating.

But it also reminds you that learning is a process.

When I make a mistake, I have an opportunity to identify what happened.

Was I playing too quickly?

Did I lose concentration?

Was I struggling with the coordination required?

Would it help to practise one hand at a time?

These questions encourage reflection.

And reflection can help make practice more effective.

One of the reasons I encourage people to learn something new is that it reminds us what being a beginner feels like.

We become accustomed to the activities we already know how to perform.

But when we try something unfamiliar, we rediscover the importance of patience, repetition and feedback.

You don’t need to play every note correctly to benefit from the experience of learning music.

Sometimes, the most useful practice begins with a note you didn’t intend to play.

6. Why Children Often Approach Mistakes Differently

Watch a young child learning to walk.

They stand.

They lose their balance.

They sit down.

They try again.

Their attempts provide opportunities to develop coordination and movement.

Of course, learning to walk involves complex developmental processes, not simply a conscious decision to learn from mistakes.

But the example illustrates something important.

Early learning often involves repeated attempts and adjustments.

As we grow older, we can become more concerned about how others judge our performance.

We may feel embarrassed about making mistakes in front of colleagues or friends.

We may begin to associate being competent with always getting things right.

But learning something new frequently requires accepting a temporary period of uncertainty.

This is one reason I believe adults can benefit from becoming beginners again.

It reminds us that we do not need to demonstrate expertise in everything we attempt.

Sometimes, curiosity is a better starting point than confidence.

7. Why Making Mistakes Can Encourage Problem-Solving

Imagine following a recipe you’ve never cooked before.

You carefully prepare the ingredients.

You follow the instructions.

But the result isn’t what you expected.

Perhaps the sauce is too thick.

Maybe the bread hasn’t risen properly.

Or perhaps the flavour is completely different from what you imagined.

You now have a choice.

You can decide that you’re simply not good at cooking.

Or you can investigate what happened.

Did you use the correct quantities?

Was the oven at the right temperature?

Did you misunderstand an instruction?

Could you approach the recipe differently next time?

This process involves problem-solving.

You identify an unexpected outcome, consider possible explanations and explore alternative approaches.

The same principle applies in education, business, sport and many everyday activities.

Mistakes can encourage us to question assumptions and develop new strategies.

But the benefits depend on how we respond.

Simply repeating an unsuccessful approach may not lead to improvement.

The value lies in recognising what didn’t work and exploring what might work better.

8. The Importance of a Growth Mindset

Psychologist Carol Dweck’s research on growth mindset has influenced discussions about learning and personal development.

A growth mindset involves recognising that abilities can often be developed through effective strategies, practice, feedback and support.

This contrasts with the belief that our abilities are entirely fixed.

Consider two people learning the same unfamiliar skill.

One makes a mistake and concludes:

“I’m just not good at this.”

The other thinks:

“I haven’t worked out how to do this yet.”

The second response leaves room for further learning.

However, having a growth mindset does not mean that effort alone guarantees success.

People have different abilities, circumstances and access to resources.

Effective learning also requires appropriate strategies, opportunities and support.

The important lesson is that a mistake does not necessarily define someone’s potential.

It may simply indicate that a different approach is needed.

9. Why Business Leaders Should Encourage Learning From Mistakes

Mistakes are not limited to classrooms and personal hobbies.

They also occur in organisations.

Businesses make decisions using the information available at the time.

Sometimes those decisions produce unexpected outcomes.

A new product may not attract customers.

A marketing campaign may underperform.

A process may prove less efficient than expected.

Effective leaders need to distinguish between avoidable negligence and reasonable experimentation.

Serious safety failures or misconduct require appropriate accountability.

But when employees are punished for every unsuccessful idea, they may become reluctant to experiment or raise concerns.

This can reduce opportunities for learning and innovation.

Psychological safety is an important concept here.

It refers to a shared belief that people can speak up, ask questions and acknowledge mistakes without unnecessary interpersonal fear.

Research has linked psychological safety with team learning behaviours.

For CEOs and business leaders, the challenge is to create environments where people can learn from errors while maintaining high standards.

A useful leadership question is:

“What can we learn from this, and what should we do differently?”

That question can be more productive than simply asking who deserves the blame.

10. Mistakes, Brain Injury and Rebuilding Confidence

My experience of living with a brain injury has shaped the way I think about learning, resilience and personal development.

Following a brain injury, some people experience changes in memory, attention, coordination, processing speed or other abilities.

Activities that were previously familiar may become difficult.

This can affect confidence.

Someone may worry about forgetting instructions, making mistakes in conversation or struggling with everyday tasks.

These concerns deserve understanding.

In rehabilitation, errors may sometimes provide useful information about which strategies or activities require adjustment.

However, repeatedly placing someone in situations where they experience overwhelming difficulty is not necessarily helpful.

Rehabilitation needs to consider fatigue, emotional wellbeing, safety and individual abilities.

Appropriate feedback, compensatory strategies and achievable goals can help people participate in meaningful activities.

Neuroplasticity may contribute to recovery and adaptation, but it does not guarantee that every lost ability can be restored.

For me, one of the most important lessons is that making a mistake should not automatically become a judgement about our worth.

We can acknowledge difficulty while still recognising effort, progress and personal achievement.

11. Why Feedback Makes Mistakes More Useful

Imagine practising a skill incorrectly for several weeks.

You may become faster at performing the activity, but you could also reinforce an ineffective technique.

Now imagine receiving constructive feedback.

Someone explains what needs to change.

They demonstrate an alternative approach.

You practise again.

This is why feedback is such an important part of learning.

Useful feedback helps us understand the difference between our current performance and the outcome we are trying to achieve.

It should be specific enough to guide improvement.

For example, telling someone “That was wrong” provides limited information.

Explaining “Try slowing down and practising the sequence in smaller sections” gives them something practical to work on.

Feedback can come from teachers, coaches, colleagues, friends or the results of our own actions.

It can also come from digital learning tools.

But the quality of feedback matters.

Incorrect or confusing feedback can make learning more difficult.

12. Five Ways to Turn Mistakes Into Learning Opportunities

If you want to become more comfortable learning unfamiliar skills, here are five practical approaches.

1. Separate the mistake from your identity

Making an error does not mean you are unintelligent or incapable.

It means something did not happen as intended.

Focus on the action rather than making a judgement about yourself.

2. Ask what the mistake can teach you

Consider what happened and why.

Was there missing information?

Did you misunderstand the instructions?

Would a different approach help?

3. Practise with appropriate feedback

Where possible, seek guidance from someone with relevant knowledge.

Constructive feedback can help prevent repeated ineffective practice.

4. Break difficult activities into smaller steps

If a task feels overwhelming, simplify it.

Practise individual components before attempting the entire activity.

5. Recognise progress rather than demanding perfection

Notice what has improved.

You may still make mistakes, but that does not mean you are failing to learn.

Small improvements can be meaningful.

13. Why Perfectionism Can Become a Barrier

Wanting to do something well is not necessarily a problem.

High standards can encourage careful preparation and thoughtful work.

But perfectionism can become unhelpful when the fear of making mistakes prevents us from acting.

Someone may avoid writing because they believe every sentence must be perfect.

Another person may hesitate to apply for a job because they do not meet every requirement.

Someone else may postpone learning an instrument because they fear sounding inexperienced.

In these situations, the pursuit of perfection can prevent opportunities for growth.

A more constructive approach is to recognise that improvement often happens through practice and revision.

Your first attempt does not need to be your final result.

A first draft can be edited.

A difficult musical passage can be practised.

An unfamiliar skill can be developed gradually.

The goal is not to celebrate carelessness.

It is to allow room for learning.

14. You Are Never Too Old to Learn From Mistakes

One of the most encouraging discoveries in neuroscience is that the brain retains the capacity for learning and adaptation throughout life.

Although some aspects of learning change with age, adulthood does not eliminate neuroplasticity.

This means that older adults can continue developing new skills.

They can learn languages.

They can explore technology.

They can take up musical instruments.

They can develop creative interests.

And they can learn from mistakes along the way.

I believe this is an important message because many people gradually stop challenging themselves.

They may feel they are too old to begin.

Or they may worry about appearing inexperienced.

But learning something new at 50, 60, 70 or beyond can be enjoyable and meaningful.

You do not need to become an expert.

You simply need to be willing to explore something unfamiliar.

And that means accepting that mistakes may be part of the experience.

15. My Challenge to You: Try Something You Might Get Wrong

I would like to leave you with a simple challenge.

This week, choose something you have never done before.

It might be cooking an unfamiliar recipe.

Learning a few words in another language.

Trying a new computer programme.

Practising a musical instrument.

Or attempting a creative activity.

Choose something safe and appropriate for your abilities.

Don’t expect to be brilliant immediately.

Instead, pay attention to what happens.

What feels difficult?

What mistakes do you make?

What feedback can you use?

What might you do differently next time?

And perhaps most importantly, can you enjoy the experience without demanding perfection?

You may discover that the activity is harder than expected.

You may also discover abilities you didn’t know you had.

Either way, you will have given yourself an opportunity to learn.

Final Thoughts: Mistakes Are Not the Opposite of Learning

We spend so much of our lives trying to avoid mistakes.

We worry about getting things wrong.

We fear embarrassment.

We compare our abilities with people who have spent years developing their skills.

But learning is rarely a perfectly smooth process.

It involves uncertainty, experimentation, feedback and adjustment.

Neuroscience helps explain why unexpected outcomes can provide information that supports learning.

Neuroplasticity reminds us that our brains retain the capacity to adapt through experience.

And resilience encourages us to respond constructively when things do not go according to plan.

This does not mean every mistake is beneficial.

Some mistakes have serious consequences and should be prevented wherever possible.

But in safe learning environments, errors can provide valuable opportunities to improve.

I started learning piano at 54, knowing that I would make mistakes.

And I still believe that the willingness to begin is more important than the expectation of immediate perfection.

A mistake does not have to be the end of your progress.

Sometimes, it can be the information that helps you take your next step.

So the next time you get something wrong, don’t immediately ask yourself why you failed.

Ask yourself what you can learn.

Because the goal of lifelong learning is not to become someone who never makes mistakes.

It is to become someone who remains willing to learn.


About Darren Jewell

Darren Jewell is a neuroresilience coach, inspirational speaker and founder of Regain the Brain.

Drawing on his lived experience of brain injury and his passion for neuroplasticity and lifelong learning, Darren encourages individuals, leaders and organisations to embrace learning, develop resilience and challenge limiting beliefs.

Through inspirational speaking and coaching, he shares practical insights into adaptability, personal development and the importance of continuing to learn throughout life.

You don’t have to get everything right to keep moving forward. You simply have to remain open to learning.

Discover more at www.regainthebrain.com.

If you’re looking for an inspirational speaker to help your team embrace learning, resilience and adaptability, explore Darren’s speaking and coaching services at Regain the Brain.

Continue your journey

Ready to discover what could become possible?

Explore Regain the Brain coaching or invite Darren to share his lived story with your audience.

Start a conversation